The man, whose identity has been kept confidential to protect his privacy, filed a lawsuit in the KwaZulu Natal High Court in Pietermaritzburg. He sought compensation for his unlawful arrest and the 54 days he spent in detention. The charges against him were eventually dropped by the National Prosecuting Authority (NPA), leading to his release. However, the court dismissed his claim for malicious prosecution against the NPA, as the charges were withdrawn before any trial could commence.
ALSO READ:Â Two South African Soldiers Repatriated After Falling Pregnant in DRC
Details of the Arrest and Detention
On March 26, 2020, the 26-year-old man was arrested at his home in Ladysmith, KwaZulu-Natal. His father had informed the investigating officer about his son’s physical condition, which should have immediately disqualified him as a suspect in the rape case. Despite this critical information, the man was detained without bail.
Initially held at a local police station, he was later transferred to the Ladysmith Correctional Centre, where he remained until his release on May 18, 2020, following the withdrawal of charges.
Conditions of Detention
During his time in custody, the man was subjected to deplorable conditions. He was confined to an overcrowded cell with inadequate facilities, including a non-functional toilet and no access to running water. These conditions underscore the severe overcrowding and inhumane treatment that are prevalent in South African prisons.
ALSO READ: Harare City Council’s Missing Business Database Sparks Concerns Over Mismanagement
Legal Proceedings and Court’s Criticism
The court strongly criticized the investigating officer for failing to verify the man’s physical condition and neglecting to communicate this information to the prosecution. This oversight led to the man’s prolonged and unjust detention.
Furthermore, the judge highlighted the dire state of South African correctional facilities, which are notoriously overcrowded and fail to meet basic human rights standards. The ruling serves as a stark reminder of the need for systemic reforms within the South African criminal justice system.
